Customer Reviews

"Absolutely the best bagels in Monmouth County. I moved here from Brooklyn and was worried I'd never find a good bagel again. Problem solved. These are the real deal — crispy outside, soft and chewy inside."

Mike R.

Google Review - Holmdel Rd

"Sunday morning tradition for our family. The everything bagels are perfectly seasoned, the Taylor Ham is always crispy, and the staff remembers our order. This place is a gem."

Sarah T.

Google Review - Holmdel Rd

"Best bagel shop around. Huge portions, fair prices, and they use Boar's Head for the deli. The cream cheese variety is unreal — try the jalapeño. My kids are obsessed with the French toast bagels."

Dan L.

Yelp - Holmdel Rd

"Ordered catering for our office and it was a massive hit. Two dozen bagels, a breakfast sandwich tray, and coffee — everything arrived fresh and hot. Already booked them for next month's meeting."

Jennifer M.

Google Review - Airport Plaza

"I'm picky about my bagels and this place delivers every single time. The sesame bagel with scallion cream cheese is perfection. And the iced coffee is strong and actually good."

Chris B.

Google Review - Airport Plaza

"New to the area and tried Bagel Boyz on a neighbor's recommendation. Had the sausage, egg and cheese on an everything with SPK. I'm hooked. Going back tomorrow for the Western omelet."

Amanda K.

Yelp - Holmdel Rd

"Finally a bagel place in Hazlet that gets it right. The staff is friendly, the shop is clean, and the food is consistently great. Love supporting a local family business."

Tom W.

Google Review - Holmdel Rd

"The gluten-free bagels are actually amazing here. As someone with celiac, I can never find good GF options. These taste like real bagels. Thank you, Bagel Boyz!"

Lisa G.

Google Review - Airport Plaza

"Hands down the best Taylor Ham egg and cheese in Monmouth County. And I've tried them all. The everything bagel at Bagel Boyz has the perfect amount of seasoning. Don't sleep on this spot."

Steve P.

Facebook - BagelBoyzNJ